On Adam and my recent day trip to Cape May, NJ we were looking for a place for lunch in between our winery visits, so we searched for a place through the Google Places app on my phone, and decided upon the one that didn't take us into "downtown" (as the wineries weren't in that location). The closest place I saw that sounded good was Lucky Bones Backwater Grille - so we went.
When we got there, I noticed that they had a sign for a grill night at Cape May Winery & Vineyards - our next stop - and on the way out I noticed a wine barrel with Cape May Winery & Vineyards logo on the barrel end, and finally on the way to the car, there was a Cape May Winery & Vineyards truck. I figured they had some partnership going - I later learned at the winery that they are actually owned by the same person, along with a well known, fancy restaurant in town - the Washington Inn and a cute store in town that Adam had shopped at last time we were in - Love the Cook.
Anyways, back to lunch. We got there around 1:15/1:30 and the parking lot was packed, and when we got in, there was a little bit of a line. Nothing major, but in the end it just ended up being a back-up in getting people seated, not a wait.
When I looked them up on google, it said that they were known for the sandwiches and brick-fired oven pizzas - so at that point I was originally thinking a sandwich, but if Adam and I could agree on a pizza, I could easily go for that. Once I looked at the list, there were like 4 or 5 that I could easily choose from, and same for Adam. Our thoughts crossed on 2 of them and finally settled on the Shrooms and Cheese Pizza.
After we ordered and were chatting, I noticed on the wall their soup of the day, and it sounded really delicious, so Adam and I decided to ask the waitress if we could order 2 cups of that in addition to the pizza. It was a Jersey BLT Soup. I really wanted the soup without the B, but I knew that wasn't possible, so I just hoped that it wasn't too crazy with the bacon. I love tomato soup, so I hoped the tomato might be able to overpower the bacon. Im glad I took that chance, because it was perfect for me. There were small pieces of bacon bits (real ones) throughout the soup - and provided good texture, but the flavor wasn't overpowering. The tomato soup portion was DELISH - we both scarfed it down. The lettuce part was cute - provided as garnish on top. If that were on the menu when we go down there again, I would definitely order it!
Just as we finished our soup, our pizza came out. The size was perfect for Adam and I to share and I loved the thin crust that they had. It turned out to be really good, but not something that I would order over and over again. As I said, the crust was perfect for me, there were a lot of mushrooms of a few different types - unfortunately I couldn't identify which types. It wasn't cheesy at all - just the right amount - it was just missing an extra flavor of something. Not sure what additional flavor would have done the trick for me, but maybe a little bit of truffle oil (but that would have caused the price to jump). Although I said I wouldn't order it over and over again, I would order it again - but there were lots of other things on the menu that Id like to try.
Oh - and the prices were very affordable - if you go to Cape May and are looking to drive around and not stay in the historic area - I would definitely recommend this for a lunch spot.